Skid Steer vs. Compact Track Loader: Which One Should You Buy?

A skid steer is a compact loader that rides on four wheels and runs a wide range of attachments. A compact track loader is the same idea on rubber tracks. If most of your work is on concrete, asphalt or a packed barn lot, buy the wheeled skid steer. If you spend your days in mud, loose dirt, snow or on slopes, buy the compact track loader. The rest of this post explains why, and what each choice costs you in speed and upkeep.

Our stores across Indiana and Ohio carry both machines from John Deere. Here is how we walk a Customer through the decision.

What Are Skid Steers?

Skid steers are compact, engine-powered machines with lift arms that accept buckets, forks, augers, sweepers and dozens of other tools. They steer by driving the wheels on one side faster than the other, which is where the name comes from and why they can turn in their own footprint. That maneuverability is what makes them so useful in tight spaces.

Wheeled Skid Steers: Fast and Agile

Wheeled skid steers run on four rubber tires. They are best suited for hard, stable surfaces like concrete, asphalt or compacted dirt. If your work is mostly on paved areas, barn floors or other firm ground, a wheeled skid steer is likely your best option.

Wheeled models are the faster of the two. They accelerate quickly and make sharp turns, which matters when you are moving between different areas of a jobsite or working in confined spaces. Zero-radius turns let you get close to obstacles without a lot of backing and repositioning.

They also cost less to keep running. Tires are generally less expensive and easier to replace than tracks, and the undercarriage needs less attention. For many farm and shop operations, especially ones that rarely see muddy or uneven ground, that lower upkeep is the deciding factor.

The trade-off is traction. Wheeled skid steers struggle in soft, muddy or snowy conditions. The tires sink or spin, and you lose both time and productivity. If your ground is mostly flat and dry, this will rarely bother you. If you work in variable conditions through an Indiana or Ohio spring, it will.

Compact Track Loaders: Built for Tough Terrain

Compact track loaders, sometimes informally called tracked skid steers, use continuous rubber or steel tracks instead of wheels. The tracks spread the machine's weight over a larger area, which lowers ground pressure and lets the machine ride over soft, muddy or uneven ground instead of sinking into it.

If you have loose soil, sand, mud or steep slopes, tracks make the difference between working and waiting for the ground to dry. They provide better traction and stability, so you can operate where a wheeled machine would get stuck or feel tippy on a side hill. Tracked machines are also gentler on soft ground, leaving fewer ruts and less compaction on turf and fields.

The drawbacks are real. Compact track loaders are slower than wheeled models, and tracks wear faster when run on hard surfaces like concrete or asphalt. Tracks cost more to replace than tires, and they need regular cleaning and tension checks to stay in good shape.

Which Is Right for You?

The biggest factor is the terrain you work on most often, not the terrain you see a few days a year.

Wheeled skid steers are best for hard, flat surfaces. They are faster, more maneuverable and less expensive to maintain. Ideal for barns, paved lots and jobsites with firm ground.

Compact track loaders excel on soft, uneven or sloped ground. They give you better traction and stability in mud, sand or snow, but they are slower and cost more to maintain.

If your work involves a lot of moving between areas or covering ground quickly, a wheeled skid steer is the better fit. If you regularly deal with wet fields, construction sites or hilly ground, a compact track loader will keep you productive year-round. And if you already own a wheeled machine that only gets stuck a handful of days each spring, that alone is not a reason to switch. Keep it, plan around the wet weeks, and put the money into attachments.

Maintenance and Longevity

Wheeled skid steers generally need less maintenance, since tires are easier and cheaper to replace than tracks. Compact track loaders need more frequent inspections, cleaning and track tension adjustments to perform well and last.

How long tracks or tires last depends heavily on the surface they run on and how the machine is operated. Rubber tracks on concrete wear far faster than the same tracks on dirt, and tires on rough ground wear faster than tires on a shop floor. Check your operator's manual for service intervals, and ask our service team for a realistic life expectation based on your conditions. Staying on schedule with maintenance does more for the lifespan of either machine than the choice of wheels or tracks.

Equipment Options at Koenig Equipment

Our stores stock a range of skid steers and compact track loaders. The John Deere 320G is a popular wheeled skid steer for farms and shops with mostly paved or compacted surfaces. For tougher terrain, the John Deere 317G compact track loader offers the traction and stability needed for muddy fields or construction sites. You can compare models side by side on our comparison page.

Both machines run a wide variety of attachments, from buckets and forks to augers and sweepers. Our staff can help you match attachments to the work you actually do and the ground you do it on. Both can also be financed through Koenig Equipment with John Deere Financial; see our current offers page for what is available now.

Find Your Skid Steer at Koenig Equipment

If you are still on the fence, describe your ground to us: how much of the year it is wet, how steep it gets, and how much time you spend on pavement. That conversation usually settles wheels versus tracks in a few minutes. Stop by your nearest store or start with our equipment finder below.

Find Your Loader

Running a farm that needs both a tractor and a loader machine? See our guide to John Deere ag and compact construction equipment for farms that need both.

Find Your Nearest Store

Find parts for your 320G

Shop genuine John Deere parts that fit the 320G and 317G at Koenig Marketplace — search by your exact model to see what fits.

Not sure which compact machine is right for you?

Answer a few quick questions and Koenig will match you to the right John Deere machine for your jobsite, based on how you work and what you need.

Find the right machine →