John Deere vs. Bobcat Skid Steers: A Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to skid steers, Bobcat and John Deere are two of the most recognized names in the industry. Both brands offer robust machines with unique features and benefits that cater to various needs. In this blog, we’ll explore the strengths and advantages of each brand, focusing on performance, maintenance, cost and value, and additional considerations.

Performance and Power

Bobcat Skid Steer

• Engine Options: Bobcat offers a range of engine options, with horsepower ratings typically ranging from 25 to 100 HP, providing versatility for different applications.
  
  
• Hydraulic Performance: Known for their strong hydraulic systems, Bobcat skid steers deliver impressive ISO lifting capabilities of up to 3,400 lbs. and quick cycle times, making them ideal for demanding jobs.
  
  
• Compact Design: Many Bobcat models, like the S70, feature a compact design with small widths as low as 36 inches, which is advantageous in tight spaces and for landscaping tasks.

John Deere Skid Steer

• Powerful Performance: John Deere skid steers come equipped with powerful engines, with horsepower ranging from 25 to over 100 HP, ensuring reliable performance for heavy-duty tasks.
  
  
• Stability and Traction: With a wider wheelbase, many John Deere machines, such as the 320G, provide stability with a width of approximately 64 inches, particularly in challenging terrains, which can lead to increased safety and productivity.
  
  
• High Lift Capacity: Many John Deere models are designed for high lift capacities, with some models like the 334 P-Tier capable of lifting up to 4,000 lbs., making them suitable for heavy loads.
  
  

Ease of Maintenance

Bobcat Skid Steer 

• Accessible Maintenance Points: Bobcat skid steers are designed with maintenance in mind, featuring easy access to crucial components such as filters, fluid reservoirs, and the engine. This design simplifies routine checks and repairs, reducing the time and cost associated with upkeep.
  
  
• Durability: Known for their sturdy construction, Bobcat machines often require less frequent maintenance. Their robust design and high-quality materials can handle rigorous use in demanding environments like construction sites, helping to reduce overall downtime and service costs.

John Deere Skid Steer

• Intuitive Design: John Deere skid steers are also designed for easy maintenance, with features such as removable side panels that provide quick access to the engine and hydraulic components. This can be particularly useful for operators who perform regular maintenance in the field, ensuring machines are always in optimal condition.

• Service Alerts: Many John Deere models come equipped with advanced monitoring systems that provide service alerts. These alerts notify operators when maintenance is due, helping to prevent unexpected breakdowns and ensuring that machines remain operational for critical tasks.

Cost and Value

Bobcat Skid Steer

• Competitive Pricing: While prices vary by location and if it is new or used, Bobcat machines generally offer competitive pricing, with models starting around $30,000 - $45,000 for smaller units. This affordability makes them an attractive option for small businesses or contractors just starting, allowing for a solid investment without breaking the bank.
  
  
• Resale Value: Bobcat skid steers tend to retain their value well over time, often seeing resale values of around 60-70% of the original price after a few years. This strong resale value is essential for businesses that may upgrade their equipment regularly.
  
  

John Deere Skid Steer

• Value for Money: While John Deere skid steers may be priced slightly higher then their Bobcat counterparts, the additional features, such as John Deere's Operations Center, often lead to a greater return on investment. This is especially true for larger operations that can leverage the enhanced technology for efficiency.
  
  
• Lower Operating Costs: The durability and efficiency of John Deere machines can lead to lower operating costs over time, particularly with access to the Ops Center. This feature can help track fuel usage and maintenance schedules, allowing operators to minimize expenses associated with downtime and repairs.

Additional Considerations

When deciding between Bobcat and John Deere, it's important to consider factors beyond just performance and price.

• Customer Support and Service: John Deere is well-known for its extensive dealer network and customer support, which can be a significant advantage when maintenance and repairs are needed. Quick access to parts and services can minimize downtime, ensuring your operations run smoothly, especially in high-demand seasons.

• Technology and Innovation: John Deere’s commitment to technology is evident in features like the Ops Center, which aids in performance tracking and enhances overall efficiency. For example, the Ops Center allows users to analyze machine performance data, making it easier to optimize productivity for tasks like grading and material handling.
  
  
• Maneuverability in Tight Spaces: Bobcat skid steers are often praised for their compact size and agility, making them ideal for projects that require navigating narrow pathways or confined areas. This advantage is particularly beneficial for residential landscaping, small construction sites, or urban applications where space is limited.
• User Experience: Many operators find that John Deere machines offer a more comfortable ride and better visibility due to thoughtful ergonomic design. Features like adjustable seating and larger windows can significantly improve comfort during long hours of operation, making them suitable for projects that require extended use.

Conclusion