Published: August 18, 2025
Updated: August 18, 2025
|
The summer brings many opportunities for contractors and landowners to kick off new projects and make progress on property improvements. Small-scale construction, landscaping, or even commercial jobs don’t always require big machinery. Compact construction equipment like skid steers, track loaders, and mini excavators provides just enough strength to deliver heavy-duty results in limited space. If you plan to use compact equipment this season, you might be weighing whether to rent or buy. Both choices come with their own set of benefits, and in this blog, we’ll break down the pros and cons to help you decide what’s right for your workload and budget.
When to Rent Compact Equipment
You Only Need It For Short-Term Projects
Many people rent out compact equipment for one-time jobs or projects that last for only a couple of weeks. This is a more affordable option than buying your equipment since it allows you to pay a small weekly/daily fee instead of hefty upfront costs for equipment that will be sitting in a garage for months after the job is finished.
You Don’t Want to Handle Maintenance
Owning equipment gives you more responsibility, so along with operating costs, you’ll be liable for all maintenance and repairs. When you rent, the rental company will handle all maintenance for you, which can save you some of the stress of dealing with breakdowns. If you run into any issues, your rental company should be able to handle it for you and provide a replacement if necessary.
You Want the Latest Technology
If you want to gain access to the newest technology without dishing out a pretty penny, renting equipment allows you to experiment without making the commitment. This has the potential to improve your operations, saving you time on the job and delivering better results.
You Want the Tax Benefits
Short-term compact equipment rentals can offer significant tax advantages. Rental costs are typically fully deductible as business expenses, reducing your taxable income for the year. You can also avoid additional costs like sales tax on high-ticket machinery, interest on financed equipment, insurance premiums, and depreciation.
When to Own Compact Equipment
You Need Equipment Long-Term
Initial upfront investment might be cheaper when renting equipment, but you will save far more in the long term and get a better return on investment with equipment ownership. If you plan to utilize the equipment frequently and for an extended period of time, purchasing the equipment is likely the better option.
You Want 24/7 Access to Equipment
When you rent, there is no guarantee that the equipment you need will be available. Owning equipment allows you to use your equipment when you need it, wherever you need it, so you can work on your own time.
You Want to Expand Your Fleet and Business
If growing your business and building a strong equipment fleet is a top priority, purchasing may be the right choice. Owning equipment allows you to build equity over time and increase the overall value of your company. When you own equipment, you’re investing in long-term assets and have the opportunity to resell and invest in new equipment down the line.
In Summary…
Pros of Renting Equipment:
- Better for short-term projects
- No maintenance cost
- Tax deductions
- Access to the latest technology
Cons of Renting Equipment:
- Limited availability
- No asset value
- Higher long-term costs
Pros of Owning Equipment:
- Better return on investment over time
- Unlimited access
- Asset Allocation
- Resale Opportunities
Cons of Owning Equipment:
- Higher upfront costs
- Maintenance and repair costs
- Depreciation
What your business needs can fluctuate depending on the season. There may be times when it’s better to rent a specific model of compact equipment and other times when it’s smarter to invest fully in equipment. To determine the best option for you, it’s important to understand the demands of your job, your budget, and the short and long-term goals for your construction company. Contact our experts at Koenig Equipment today for more guidance on picking the best option for you, and find more information about our current compact construction offerings.